BUILDPLACESExploreExplainers

Explainer · Streets

Why Do Highways Run Through Downtowns?

The freeway through downtown did not arrive on an empty map. Its route reflects an era when federal highway funding, urban renewal and local politics reshaped American cities together.

The interstate system arrived in the urban renewal era

The Federal-Aid Highway Act of 1956 funded the Interstate Highway System, with the federal government paying 90 percent of construction costs. That ratio made interstate construction enormously attractive for state highway departments eager to build, and cities saw urban expressways as part of the same program.

The timing mattered. Urban highways were planned and built in the 1950s, 1960s, and 1970s, during and after a period of urban renewal that had already cleared large swaths of older city neighborhoods. Federal housing programs had been segregating metropolitan areas for decades, concentrating Black families in central cities while subsidizing white flight to new suburbs.

Route choices were political as well as technical

Engineers evaluated grades, traffic volumes, connections to regional networks, and construction cost. They also worked within a political environment in which neighborhoods varied substantially in their ability to resist a highway route.

Highways more often ran through lower-income neighborhoods and communities of color. Studies of American urban highway routing have documented the pattern repeatedly. Some routes destroyed thriving commercial and residential neighborhoods that had survived urban renewal; others went through areas that planners described as blighted, a term whose application often tracked with race.

The political process that allowed this was not usually a conspiracy. It was a set of incentives, assumptions about what neighborhoods mattered, and an institutional structure that had no requirement to weigh displacement costs against regional mobility benefits.

What the highway did to the city

An elevated freeway blocks light and creates noise along its corridor. An at-grade freeway severs streets and cuts off walking routes. A depressed freeway is more benign at the surface but can still be a barrier and often occupies land that had other value.

Real estate near urban highways typically lost value in the years following construction. Research has documented persistent effects: lower incomes, higher vacancy rates, and reduced property values within several blocks of urban freeway corridors built in this era.

Those effects compound over decades. A neighborhood cut off from an adjacent business district in 1965 may still be economically isolated in part because of that decision, even if the physical highway is now less prominent.

Today the question is facility by facility

Many urban highways are reaching the end of their design life, which creates an unavoidable decision: rebuild in kind, redesign, or remove.

No single answer applies in every case. Some urban highways carry freight volumes or regional traffic that cannot easily be rerouted. Others are structurally separate from the regional network and carry traffic that could be absorbed by surface streets or reduced by better transit.

The recent acceleration of highway removal and redesign projects, from the Embarcadero in San Francisco, completed in 1991, to ongoing projects in Rochester, New Orleans, and Syracuse, reflects both the age of the infrastructure and a changed political and planning context in which the original cost-benefit calculation can now be revisited.

The long-term impact shows up at neighborhood scale. A freeway may connect distant destinations while severing the grid of local streets beneath it. Homes and businesses are displaced, crossings become difficult, and parcels beside the corridor lose connections they once had. Understanding that history matters when cities discuss caps, removals, or boulevard conversions today: the objective is often to repair damage as much as to move traffic.