Explainer · Streets
What Is Highway Removal?
There is a moment in a highway-removal debate when the practical question becomes unavoidable: where does the traffic go? Cities that have removed highways offer more than one answer.
Why cities consider removal
Many urban highways are reaching the age when major reconstruction is unavoidable. That creates a choice: rebuild the facility largely as it exists, redesign it, or remove part of it.
Removal is usually considered where a highway carries less traffic than expected, duplicates another route, has imposed substantial costs on nearby neighborhoods, or occupies land whose urban value has changed.
The decision is not simply about whether highways are good or bad. It's about what transportation function the segment still performs and whether another network can carry that function more effectively.
What replaces the highway
A removed freeway does not leave an empty trench forever. Cities usually reconnect the local street grid and then decide how the recovered land should be used.
Some projects replace the freeway with an urban boulevard. Others create development parcels, parks, transit space, or combinations of uses.
The value of the project depends heavily on those choices. Removing infrastructure can reconnect a neighborhood physically while still producing little public benefit if the replacement plan is weak.
What happens to traffic
Some trips shift to other roads. Some use different routes or times. A share may move to transit, walking, or biking where those options exist. Some trips disappear because people adjust destinations or travel behavior.
The amount varies by city and network, which is why traffic modeling matters.
Highway-removal debates often become arguments about whether traffic will “vanish.” A better question is how the entire transportation system will adapt and what tradeoffs the city is willing to accept in exchange for the land and connections it regains.
Why the history matters
Urban freeway construction frequently cut through neighborhoods with limited political power, including many Black communities. Homes and businesses were demolished, street networks severed, and nearby land exposed to noise and pollution.
That history does not automatically determine the right engineering decision today, but it is part of the public decision because the infrastructure shaped who benefited from regional mobility and who carried its local costs.
Removing an elevated expressway can reconnect blocks and return land to public use, but the traffic and access questions are real. What trips are currently using the road? Which can shift to other routes or modes? What happens to freight and adjacent streets? The best proposals test those scenarios before building a park or boulevard. The urban benefits are greatest when the replacement street network is designed as carefully as the demolition.