BUILDPLACESExploreExplainers

Explainer · Land

What Is Inclusionary Zoning?

A market-rate apartment building may also have homes with restricted rents or prices. Inclusionary zoning is the policy behind that mix, and the details determine what actually gets built.

Affordable homes inside market-rate development

Inclusionary zoning, often called inclusionary housing, is a local policy that requires or encourages residential developers to make a share of units in a new project available to lower-income households at below-market rents or prices.

A common formulation might require 10 to 20 percent of units to be affordable to households earning 80 percent of area median income. The exact percentages, income thresholds, and program rules vary considerably by jurisdiction.

The economics of the requirement

A below-market unit in a market-rate project generates less revenue than the other units in the same building. Depending on how a program is designed and local market conditions, it may be absorbed by the developer's margin, passed to buyers or renters in the market-rate units, reflected in a lower land price that sellers accept, or combined with offsetting incentives the city provides.

In a strong real-estate market, the math can work and produce affordable units at no direct public cost. In a weaker market, the requirement can push some projects into infeasibility, reducing the overall supply of housing. That's why many inclusionary programs include offsets: additional building height, reduced parking requirements, or expedited permits in exchange for including affordable units.

What makes a unit stay affordable

The resale and re-rental rules determine how long affordability lasts. A unit that is sold below market to an income-qualified household but then resold at market rate after five years provides temporary affordability for one household, not a permanent community asset.

Stronger programs require deed restrictions, ground leases, or long-term regulatory agreements that keep rents or resale prices within program limits for 30, 55, or 99 years, regardless of who owns the unit.

Community land trusts are one tool for permanent affordability: the trust retains ownership of the land, which removes the land value from the resale price permanently.

What it can and cannot do

Inclusionary zoning is not designed to produce large numbers of affordable units. Even at 20 percent, a 100-unit building produces 20 affordable apartments while adding 80 units to the market-rate supply. Its value is in integrating affordable units into market-rate buildings and neighborhoods, and in capturing some public benefit from private development.

It works best as one tool among many. Cities that rely on inclusionary zoning alone as their primary affordable-housing strategy tend to produce limited numbers of units, particularly if the requirement discourages development in markets where the math is already difficult.

A developer evaluating a project must make the entire building pencil out, including its restricted-price units. That's why the required percentage, income levels, length of restrictions, density bonuses, and local rents are linked. A program that produces homes in one strong market might stall construction in a weaker one. The policy's effect is measured in actual homes and long-term affordability, not only in the percentage printed in an ordinance.