Explainer · Planning
What Are Parking Minimums?
A minimum parking requirement can decide how much land a shop needs, how many apartments fit on a lot, and whether a small project can be built at all.
The spaces that come with the building
A city may require two parking spaces for every apartment, or a set number for every thousand square feet of commercial floor area. The spaces have to fit somewhere, whether residents or customers need them or not.
Parking minimums became common in American zoning in the automobile era. They were meant to prevent cars from spilling onto surrounding streets. But the requirement also adds pavement, cost and sometimes a parking structure to projects that might otherwise occupy less land.
What minimums cost
A surface parking space costs roughly $5,000 to $10,000 to construct and occupies about 330 square feet including drive aisles. A structured space in a parking garage costs $25,000 to $50,000 or more. Those costs are embedded in development budgets regardless of whether tenants or buyers actually want or use the parking.
The space requirement also directly limits what can be built. A minimum requiring two spaces per unit may add more land area for parking than the dwelling units themselves. On a small lot, that calculation can make a project infeasible or eliminate the possibility of ground-floor retail. In neighborhoods where residents own fewer cars or rely on transit, the required parking spaces may sit largely empty while adding cost to every unit.
A growing number of cities have eliminated them
Buffalo, New York eliminated parking minimums citywide in 2017, the first large American city to do so. Minneapolis followed in 2021, Austin in 2023. California eliminated parking minimums near transit statewide through AB 2097, which took effect in 2023 for most projects within half a mile of high-quality transit.
Early evidence from reform cities suggests that development near transit often does not produce the parking demand the old minimums assumed. In many cases, developers build parking voluntarily based on market demand, just less of it than codes previously required.
What the reform debate is actually about
Critics of eliminating minimums often focus on spillover parking in adjacent neighborhoods when residents of new projects without dedicated parking use street spaces.
That concern deserves attention in dense neighborhoods with limited street parking. It does not follow that every new building must include dedicated parking. Residential parking permit programs, priced street parking, and good transit can manage spillover while avoiding the cost and land-use consequences of mandated off-street spaces.
The deeper argument is simpler: cities should not require private development to build infrastructure for a mode of transportation as a condition of building anything else.
A requirement for one or two spaces per apartment influences much more than the size of a parking lot. On a small parcel, a ramp or parking aisle can reduce the number of homes that fit; in a larger project, structured parking can add significant construction cost. Removing a minimum lets a developer choose an amount appropriate to the site and market. It doesn't forbid parking, and developers still have to satisfy lenders, tenants, and accessibility obligations.
See it in practice
Explore the people and projects connected to this subject.
- Ryan Johnson · Tempe, Arizona
- Culdesac · Tempe, Arizona