Explainer · Planning
What Is a Rail-Trail?
Railroads laid out long, relatively gentle routes through difficult terrain. When service ends, those corridors can become unusually useful paths for people on foot and bicycle.
The railroad already solved the route problem
Rail-trails reuse former railroad corridors as public paths. What makes them valuable is the same thing that made them valuable to railroads: a continuous, uninterrupted right-of-way that runs through communities without highway crossings, steep grades, or the property-boundary complications that make assembling a new linear corridor so difficult.
The Rails-to-Trails Conservancy has counted more than 25,000 miles of rail-trails completed in the United States, with thousands more miles in development. That network represents accumulated corridor that no city would be able to assemble today at anything like its existing cost.
Grades that work for trains work for bikes
Railroads were built to maximum grades of 1 to 3 percent on most mainlines, because locomotives cannot push heavy loads up steeper inclines. Those same gradual grades make rail-trail corridors accessible to cyclists, wheelchair users, and people with limited mobility who cannot use trails with conventional hiking grades.
That combination of gentle grade and grade separation from vehicle traffic makes rail-trails unusually accessible compared to on-street bike routes or natural-surface trails in hilly terrain.
Ownership is the complication
A railroad corridor may be owned outright in fee simple, held as an easement over private land, or some combination of both, and the relevant documentation may go back 150 years.
Federal railbanking law, passed in 1983, allows active railroad easements on out-of-service corridors to be converted to trail use without the easement reverting to adjacent landowners. Without that mechanism, abandonment of a railroad corridor would trigger reversion of the right-of-way to the adjoining property owners, eliminating the corridor and its connectivity permanently.
Railbanking preserves the corridor for possible future rail reactivation while allowing trail use in the meantime. Most of the major rail-trail conversions in the United States have used it.
A rail-with-trail is a different challenge
When a trail runs beside an active railroad rather than replacing one, the project requires coordination with the operating railroad, clearances from moving trains, fencing specifications, and sometimes grade-crossing agreements.
Those requirements add complexity and cost, and railroad operators vary in their willingness to engage. But rail-with-trail projects can serve corridors where active freight or passenger rail cannot be displaced, giving communities trail access in places that would otherwise be landlocked.
A former rail corridor can offer an unusually direct route through a region because railways were built with manageable grades and long continuous alignments. Turning one into a trail still requires agreements over land, safe street crossings, bridges, maintenance, and sometimes the preservation of future rail options. Its value emerges when the corridor connects actual destinations, not merely when a ribbon is cut at a scenic segment.
See it in practice
Explore the people and projects connected to this subject.
- The High Line · New York, New York