BuildplacesThe built environment, explored

An “American Shenzhen” Actually Isn’t Ambitious Enough

If you’re as terminally online as I am, you’ve probably seen someone push the idea of establishing “an American Shenzhen,” a special economic zone somewhere in the United States (typically somewhere in Texas) that mimics the one in China driving so much of its technological progress.

The appetite and excitement for something like this makes sense. It feels bold. But for a country as big, diverse, and capable as ours, I want to make the case that it’s actually still dreaming too small.

Trying to out-China China forfeits America’s built-in advantage: a culture where innovation can come from anywhere, and anyone can build the next great thing.

America’s strength has never been one exceptional place, it was a nation full of places where people could rise. So we shouldn’t shrink our dreams to one engineered zone. We should be dreaming in regions, in systems, and in a country that unleashes its full geography.

Why the Shenzhen Idea Emerged

The idea was born from a real and well-placed frustration that America makes it impossibly hard to build big things fast. We’ve buried ourselves in red tape, and stagnation has followed.

So now, many of our most prolific builders and innovators understandably want a fresh start. And Shenzhen offers a very seductive model: one place with better rules, faster timelines, and a clear runway. And one that invites a kind of global gravitas that, in some ways, almost feeds the beast on pure “aura” (as the kids would say).

It also just feels much easier than attempting to push back against the entirety of the national stagnancy and the various political systems and levels of government that have created it.

Why a Single Shenzhen-Style Zone Isn’t Enough

While the forces driving the appetite for an American Shenzhen are worth considering and wrestling with, I want to suggest that leaning into a single special economic zone is not only the wrong solution, it’s actually not ambitious enough.

To pursue a singular zone is essentially to concede the rest of the country is beyond repair. And if our best and brightest minds are willing to do that, we’ve essentially hung it up. We’ve said “this is the best we’re going to get.”

And let’s be fair for a second: it’s not that the idea is in any way stupid. There’s a lot of good that could come from a zone like this. Speed, flexibility, innovation, community, and more.

But it would both stop far short of the national economic revival we need and, more notably, would become an unintentional stumbling block to that very revival for a few different reasons.

The Great Sorting Problem

America is already self-sorting by income, education, ideology, and religion, and has been for over a decade in what Bill Bishop famously called “the Big Sort.”

A single American super-zone the scale of Shenzhen would only further feed into this driver of national stagnancy and ideological/intellectual homogeneity that’s contributed so much to our decline in a number of ways.

It also creates a sort of ivory tower innovation complex, similar to the one that already exists to a degree in Silicon Valley, that removes even more of our greatest minds from the communities experiencing the problems they’re trying to solve. It builds a trickle-down prosperity model that’s an inferior distant cousin to the true abundance we can actually create.

The goal shouldn’t be one brain-drain magnet region. It should be creating an entire series of places that foster and support innovation and economic productivity. It should be creating frameworks and systems that make it so anywhere in America can be one of those places.

While some will reasonably present that a single super-zone could be a template for other regions to copy, that’s just not what we’ve seen in American politics to this point, making it hard to believe that would suddenly change.

To the degree places copy each other to build tech hubs and attract economic activity, it’s seldom through creating genuinely powerful economic conditions overall, and almost exclusively through engaging in the race to the bottom to hand out subsidies and tax breaks to specific companies that make for attractive ribbon cutting ceremonies.

In all likelihood, aspiring copycat areas (even well-meaning ones) would presumably take the worst possible lessons from such a place here in the U.S., not the positive ones.

Dreaming a More American Dream

There’s another problem at play here: Throwing the word “American” in front of Shenzhen doesn’t make it American at all.

If you opt to avoid more cynical interpretations of what “American” means, a zoned exception where the rules are different is a distinctly non-American idea.

To condense the “land of opportunity” to a single zip code (or series of zip codes) is to condense the degree to which America is, well, American.

Shenzhen works in China because it’s intentionally an exception. China doesn’t want Shenzhen-type conditions in the rest of the country, because it wants aggressive government control, involvement, and regulation.

Americans, especially our most prolific builders and innovators, should want the opposite. And it’s hard to picture a realistic scenario where concessions of that scale are made in a singular place without seeing equal and opposite concessions required in other places. If we want America to be a great place to build, are we really prepared to throw that much of it to the wolves to get there?

Instead of mimicking China, we should be dreaming an American dream. America’s competitive advantage has always been its regional diversity, commitment to a basic capitalistic framework, vast array of different specialized areas, and the geographic miracle it finds itself placed into.

And at its best, a widespread belief that anyone from anywhere can make something of themselves, and the cultural, economic, technological, and political contributions that have come from the nobody-from-nowheres who dared to buy into that belief.

A better, builder-enabling American future is not one engineered miracle city or region, it’s multiple connected regions that collectively outperform anything one place alone can do.