Building Resilient Places for an Uncertain Future
How well would our towns and cities function if the systems they depend on stopped working?
It’s been an interesting week for anyone who enjoys reading the news and then trying to sleep at night.
The Pentagon is reportedly developing plans for major American military installations to sustain essential operations for up to 90 days without the civilian infrastructure they normally depend on. Meanwhile, European governments have been encouraging citizens to prepare for emergencies, with the EU recommending that households maintain at least 72 hours’ worth of essential supplies.
There’s something striking about the contrast. The military is considering how to keep entire installations operating without the services they normally rely on, while ordinary households are being encouraged to stock up on enough supplies to get through a few difficult days. But what about the towns and cities where most of us actually live?
There’s only so much a household can do with a few days of emergency supplies if the community around it can no longer provide essential services.
We spend an enormous amount of time thinking about how to make our communities better places to live, from creating more economic opportunity to building beautiful neighborhoods. But one of the more overlooked parts of building a great place is considering how well it functions on its worst day.
And given how the 2020s have gone so far (pandemics, wars, AI cyberattacks, etc.), that seems worth taking seriously.
There’s simply too much gunpowder in the chamber to take an uneventful future for granted. I hope we never have to find out how independently our communities could function, and I’m not advocating for abandoning the abundance that comes from living in an interconnected world.
But we should be building towns and regions capable of sustaining essential parts of everyday life for an extended period if they had to.
I suspect we’d end up with better places to live even if we never had to test them.
What happens when gas stations run dry?
Remember the Colonial Pipeline shutdown in 2021?
After a ransomware attack prompted the pipeline’s operator to halt operations, drivers across parts of the Southeast found themselves waiting in long lines for gasoline. Some stations ran dry. Operations resumed in less than a week, but the disruption showed how quickly a problem with infrastructure most people had never heard of could reach into everyday life.
Now imagine the interruption lasts a month.
In many parts of the country, getting a gallon of milk requires getting behind the wheel of a car. You might live half a mile from a grocery store and still have no practical way to walk there because the route involves crossing a highway or navigating roads without sidewalks.
We tend to discuss walkability as something that makes a neighborhood more pleasant. There’s a more fundamental advantage, though, to living somewhere that doesn’t become inaccessible the moment gasoline becomes difficult to obtain.
During a prolonged fuel shortage, the difference between two otherwise similar towns could be enormous. In one, nearly everyone would need gasoline to get groceries or reach work. In the other, people could still accomplish a meaningful share of their daily errands on foot.
Plenty of people would still need cars, particularly in rural communities. But reducing the number of essential trips that require one would make a difference.
And we don’t need to turn every American town into lower Manhattan to make progress. Sometimes it’s as simple as connecting two neighborhoods that have always been separated by a dead-end street, or making it possible to walk to a shopping center that’s been just across the road for years.
These improvements can save families money and give children more freedom to explore their communities. During a fuel shortage, they’d become considerably more valuable.
Surrounded by farms, dependent on distant food
I’ve always found it remarkable that you can drive through miles of American farmland, past cattle grazing in fields and crops stretching to the horizon, and still have almost no idea where the food in the nearest grocery store actually came from.
In many cases, it traveled hundreds or thousands of miles to get there.
That’s partly because the agricultural economy surrounding a community isn’t necessarily set up to feed the people who live in it. Much of the corn grown across the Midwest goes toward livestock feed or ethanol, while cattle raised on nearby farms may have to travel considerable distances to be slaughtered and processed. By the time meat reaches a local supermarket, it may have passed through facilities in several other states.
Under normal circumstances, there’s good reason for this. Specialization and large-scale processing have helped make food more affordable and widely available. But it creates a strange possibility: during a prolonged disruption to transportation or processing, people living in some of America’s most productive agricultural regions could struggle to get food produced practically in their own backyards.
We got a taste of that during COVID, when meatpacking plant closures left some farmers with animals they couldn’t get processed even as grocery stores struggled to keep meat stocked.
It makes me wonder how many agricultural regions could feed a meaningful share of their own residents if they suddenly needed to.
For some, the biggest obstacle might be the lack of nearby processing facilities. Others would need better ways to get food from local producers into grocery stores, restaurants, and institutional kitchens. And building that capacity would require businesses that can survive during ordinary times, when they’re competing against some of the most efficient food suppliers in the world.
That’s where the opportunity gets interesting. Schools, hospitals, and other large buyers already purchase enormous quantities of food. Could some of that spending help support regional processors and distributors, giving nearby farmers another market while making the local food supply a little less dependent on distant facilities?
I wouldn’t expect every region to grow everything its residents eat. That would be impractical, and we’d lose a lot of what makes our food system so productive. But it seems worth asking why so many places that produce food for the rest of America have so little infrastructure for supplying their own communities.
There’s a business opportunity in answering that question, and potentially a much more dependable food supply for the people who live there.
Why does a perfectly good house become unlivable?
During the winter storm that hit Texas in 2021, millions of people lost electricity in freezing temperatures. Pipes burst, water systems failed, and families spent days trying to keep warm inside their own homes.
The storm also exposed how poorly equipped many homes are to handle prolonged outages. We build houses that are supposed to last 50 or 100 years, yet in extreme temperatures, some can become unsafe to occupy after just a few hours without heating or air conditioning.
There’s a lot we could change about how we build them. Better insulation, high-performance windows, and more attention to how a building handles sunlight and shade can help keep indoor temperatures manageable during an outage. Many of those same improvements can also lower utility bills over the life of a house.
We should be paying more attention to these things when designing and building homes, especially in places where extreme temperatures are already a concern. The challenge is figuring out which improvements deliver enough value over the life of a home to justify their upfront cost. Lower energy bills, greater comfort, and a house that stays safer during an outage all belong in that calculation.
And then there’s the infrastructure that makes those homes livable in the first place.
Backup generators are common at water treatment plants, but during a prolonged regional outage, keeping them supplied with fuel could become a serious challenge. That’s one reason more communities should explore ways to keep water service running even when their own facilities can’t operate, whether through more dependable backup power or connections to neighboring water systems that could help during an emergency.
The same questions apply to hospitals, nursing homes, and other facilities where losing electricity can quickly become a matter of life and death.
We already spend enormous sums building and maintaining this infrastructure. More of that investment should be directed toward making sure it can continue doing its job when the grid goes down.
Remember when we figured out outdoor dining?
For years, getting permission to put a few tables in the street could involve months of paperwork, public hearings, and negotiations over parking spaces.
Then COVID happened, and suddenly we figured it out in a matter of weeks.
Restaurants that had been struggling to survive were allowed to take over parking spaces and portions of streets. Sidewalks filled with tables, and people started spending time in places that had previously been reserved almost exclusively for cars. Some of the arrangements were terrible, but plenty were great. I remember wondering why it had taken a pandemic for us to try something so obvious.
And then, almost as quickly as we’d figured it out, we started taking it away.
I understand why some temporary structures had to go. But the eagerness to return everything to its previous condition was frustrating, especially after we’d spent years watching cities struggle to make even modest improvements to their streets.
There’s a practical reason to preserve the ability to do this. If another respiratory pandemic makes indoor gatherings difficult, restaurants and other businesses would have more options for staying open. But I’d also love to live in a country where making room for outdoor dining doesn’t require a public health emergency.
The lesson extends beyond restaurants. Schools with better ventilation can reduce the spread of airborne illness, while libraries and community centers designed to serve as cooling shelters give people somewhere to go during dangerous heat waves. These are useful investments even when everything is going fine.
What interests me most about the outdoor dining experiment, though, is how quickly we managed to change things once we decided we had to. Rules that had seemed practically immovable turned out to be surprisingly flexible.
I’d like to think we could hold on to some of that willingness to experiment without waiting for another crisis to force our hand.
The time to build these things is before we need them
When a tornado tears through a town, neighboring communities can usually send equipment and emergency personnel. Businesses elsewhere help replace damaged services, and governments provide resources for recovery.
But what happens when the surrounding communities are dealing with the same emergency?
During a major cyberattack or prolonged fuel disruption, large parts of the country could find themselves competing for limited supplies. That’s a difficult time to discover that neighboring water systems have no way to support one another.
And by the time a crisis arrives, it’s too late to start building much of what we’d need. You can’t suddenly open a regional meatpacking plant or connect neighboring water systems that have operated independently for decades. Even something as seemingly straightforward as making it easier to get around town without a car depends on decisions about streets and development that should have been made years earlier.
You can’t create those things with an emergency declaration.
We need more regions asking what they could reasonably sustain on their own for a few months if they absolutely had to.
Regional chambers of commerce and economic development organizations could bring businesses and public institutions together to examine their most consequential dependencies. Which investments would make sense even without an emergency? What could realistically be accomplished over the next decade?
For many communities, the regional scale is probably the right place to start. Smaller towns won’t have the resources to support every essential service independently, but working with their neighbors gives them a better chance.
I suspect the exercise would also uncover economic opportunities that don’t emerge from ordinary development planning. An investment addressing a regional vulnerability might create the conditions for a new business to succeed.
Building for the world we’re entering
I hope we never have to find out how long our communities could function without the systems we’ve come to depend on.
I’d much rather spend the next several decades enjoying the benefits of a peaceful, prosperous, and increasingly interconnected world. Modern life is extraordinary in ways that previous generations could scarcely have imagined, and we should be careful about romanticizing a past in which communities had fewer options and much less material abundance.
But we should also be willing to ask whether some of the choices we’ve made in pursuit of convenience and efficiency have left our communities more vulnerable than they need to be.
Most of us have very little influence over the decisions that could determine whether the coming decades are peaceful or turbulent. We have considerably more influence over the places where we live.
Building resilience into our communities would give us more room to maneuver when circumstances become difficult. We’d still depend on the wider world for an enormous amount of what makes modern life possible, and that’s a good thing. But we’d have more options when those connections become unreliable.
We spend a lot of time imagining the best possible futures for the places we build. There’s room in that ambition to consider how they’ll hold up when the future is considerably less accommodating.
And if we’re fortunate enough never to find out, we’ll still have built better places.