Don’t Quit on America’s Cities
In a time of national instability and uncertainty, cities give us something to invest in that stands the test of time.
As I get set to turn 30 in a few weeks, I’m reflecting on how much of the last decade would’ve made no sense if I tried to explain it to my 20-year-old self back in 2016.
And it’s led me into a bit of a humble conclusion: I used to think I could tell where things are heading, but I have no idea what’s going to happen next. I’m pretty sure just about anyone who tells you they do is lying. And if they’re correct, then they’re probably just lucky.
The instability and uncertainty of our current time can be arresting. Defeating. Why bother building in such an unknown, troubling, discouraging environment? But for urbanists, I want to argue there’s never been a better, or at least more important, time to build.
Cities are very different than nations. Nations all come and go. Government structures and types cycle through the ages. But cities stand the test of time:
- Modern Italy is less than 200 years old, but Rome has existed for almost 3,000 years.
- The modern Greek state was established in 1974, but Athens has existed for 5,000 years.
- Modern Syria is only about 80 years old, but Damascus has existed for at least 9,000 years.
America is approaching its 250th birthday, which is both an exciting milestone and an unsettling one, because it puts the country squarely in the range of where empires begin to fall (220+ years).
But no matter what happens to The United States of America as a political entity, there’s one thing that’s going to be true: there will still be people and places on the American section of the North American continent in 5, 10, 50, and 100 years, regardless of what country or political unit they are controlled by.
So no matter what comes next, or what comes after what comes next, urbanists have a unique source of at least purpose: There will always be cities to invest in and make better.
The political landscape above the city-level will certainly influence specifically what that can/will look like in the years to come. But the ability and work to create places that make the lives of our neighbors better never stops.
This may not have the optimism or motivational power of a locker room pre-game speech, but that’s because our work is not an optimism opportunity. It’s a service opportunity. Serving others is a call in all circumstances and moments in history, and the ones who are remembered are the ones who choose to stay and serve their neighbors in plague, war, and famine.
Our call is not primarily to be hopeful, but to embrace the opportunity to be a source of hope for others by picking up the literal and proverbial shovels and continuing to do the work. To continue to serve. To continue to be living proof that someone still gives a damn, and someone still cares.
And in doing that, we become a source of hope for others.
It’s a planted seed that will yield optimism in its season, but will first inevitably be met by the weeds of fear and skepticism. The most courageous part about continuing to fight is choosing to take a machete to the mile-tall grass telling you there’s no point.
But the incredible thing about cities, unlike nations, is that the hardest part is taken care of already: It’s not our job to keep cities alive at the most basic level. History tells us that cities will continue to exist so long as humanity itself does, which is not true of nations.
So believing in cities actually doesn’t require much in the way of faith. History makes it so seeing is believing.
Our job is not to be emergency surgeons. It’s to be gardeners.
Because cities may always exist, and may always be full of lives, but what is not promised is that they will be full of life.
That’s our work.
And in turbulent times, it’s the most sensible, logical, resilient, stable work we can find. Because in some form, it’s the kind of work that never goes away, regardless of how the nations rage.
In many ways, it’s also the path to recovering one of the few things that is truly, universally considered to be American: a pioneering spirit. We’re the people of the gold rushers, the blazers of the Oregon trail, of taking the new frontier.
The frontier in our age is no longer the Western plains. It’s the ignored, politically spat-on cities.
Our cities are calling us to look at them and say “These are not ruins, these are bones.”
Bones of what, and for who? Some of that is up to us. Some of it is not.
But stepping into being the ones that shape the part that is, that’s American. That’s a pioneering spirit.
And it’s the only work we know will be there for us no matter how things play out.
There may not be anything politically “stable” about a city in terms of real politics, or even in terms of how stable a place’s quality of life is. But in a time where many are questioning if America is long for a 50-state united country, the best way to invest in its stability, healing, and future is by investing in the parts of it that, almost by default, have achieved a sort of immortality: its cities.
Whether or not America is killed, or kills itself, its cities will still be there in one form or another. And they’ll need caretakers.
Whether or not you’ve quit on America, don’t quit on its cities.